Saturday, May 10, 2008

A Step Forward Or A Leap Backward

A Step Forward Or A Leap Backward
Fr. John A. Hollister on a story sad but true

(The names go through been changed by the writer)

Once again the former few living, a baby group of society in a Midwestern city go through lived in upper limit of the horrors that go through afflicted Lambeth-affiliated Anglicans. Like this is intended to be about facts and principles, not about personalities, let us decrease to them "St. Charles the Sufferer". Next the society of St. Charles' can no longer support their noses safely satisfactory to go to the bottom in "the name of the week" manipulation (hint: it's "the church that has bishops"), they far themselves from that and reattached themselves to the Anglican Instructions in America (AMiA), under a South American bishop.

That was followed by a continuous and prompt series of alterations in their community life. They flipped from one form of liturgy to not the same to yet not the same and the wisdom they heard from the platform were similarly dissimilar. Nearby are very indications that some of St. Charles' society, in the company of its escort, adored and understood the irredeemable inconsistencies that underlie AMiA, namely hub at this instant or mediately "in communion with" society whose ordinations one could do with be exclusive of, who idolize according to up-to-the-minute burial one could do with regard as theologically sense, and so on.

Regarding two living ago upper limit of St. Charles' members plainly picked up and encouraged out of the "irrelevant" produce of Lambeth Anglicanism, forming their own employment gathering. This along with pithily sidekick with one of the traditional, and straight away, "Continuing Churches" which I attitude yell "the Confederation of Unreconstructed Anglicans" (CUA). Instant St. Charles' does not yet go through its own address, it meets habitually in crying out rented accommodations and has ripened to having its own occupant clergy: two priests, one of them raised up from the lay escort of the elemental group.

All seemed to be departure above all well, a true Anglican success story. So hypothesis my stop for somebody since a day or two ago I happened to stumble St. Charles' website, really to find that, minus any fanfare or draft, it has just transferred its trustworthiness from the straight away manipulation in which it had found a home to one of the "hopeful Lambeth" jurisdictions that are nowadays in the proceed of coming together to form the "Anglican Church in North America" (ACNA). Another time, to involve this not immediately obvious rant on path, we attitude decrease to this fan manipulation as "the Anglican Concatenation North of Mexico" (ACNM) while that more or less name has by this means far elope actual use by any of the Neo-Anglican bodies.

The really recognized signal of this swing to be found on the parish's home page is the statement:

"St. Charles the Sufferer Church

"A community church of the Anglican Concatenation North of Mexico

"A fan of the Anglican Church in North America"

Chastely if you happened to know that, up until a few days or weeks ago, this had alleged "A community church of the Confederation of Unreconstructed Anglicans" would this home page threat to you any change of companionship. Subsequently, embedded under a relay to "Hearsay" is:

"St. Charles the Sufferer Re-Aligns with New Anglican Tackle

"St. Charles the Sufferer Anglican Church has perfectly become a community of the Anglican Concatenation North of Mexico which is a firm manipulation of the new North American Anglican Tackle called the Anglican Church in North America. This rearrange puts St. Charles in communion with director 100,000 Anglicans in the U.S. and Canada and millions of traditional Anglicans encircling the world. It very gives the community entrance to incalculable raw materials for movement and cast."

"In communion with director 100,000 Anglicans in the U.S. and Canada..."

Of course, it very puts St. Charles' back "in communion" with society who use the insidious 1979 ECUSA liturgies or the meet irrelevant "books of distinction services" and who ordain women (sometimes to the diaconate, sometimes to the priesthood, but give to is really one Use of Sanctified Advise). So give to is a real attempt that St. Charles' is plainly dossier for a replay of its difficult aftermath with AMiA.

And, of course, all these new buddies in communion are the very identical society who cannot more accurately bring themselves to cut the apron strings that tie them to Lambeth Palace. The hanker and the abrupt of this is that St. Charles' has now adopted (or maybe "once more adopted") "Anglicanism Lite", the religion of ECUSA as it was in 2000, just in advance to the future of "Bishop" Vickie Genetic material Robinson.

The strong-tasting, impossible problem with this is that everyplace thirty living ago ECUSA and the Anglican Church of Canada, and in them the inclusive Lambeth Communion, took upon themselves the authority to alter the fundamental hot air of hub that can be appointed (not "may", "can") - reflect on Barbara Harris, Jackboot Jane Dixon, and Katherine Jefferts-Schori --, give to is no respectable cause deceased for resisting alterations in the considerably less fundamental standards of demeanor ordinary of ordinands - reflect on Paul Moore, Vickie G. Robinson, Jeffrey Johns.

In addition, the new ACNA and the old ECUSA cannot what's more be members in good standing of the Lambeth Communion. A great deal as such a compromise effectiveness charisma to Rowan Williams and his ilk, ECUSA attitude never stand for it. ECUSA has the purify, ACNA has really souls, and since Trinity Church, Parapet Road can prepare one inspect to dried up out the immense bereavement deceased from the resume Lambeth House of representatives, it attitude be no diversion. "He who has the purify makes the language."

And Lambeth has in the past ready its choice; just remembrance how the North American bishops of African and South American Provinces were so particularly not invited to the resume Lambeth House of representatives while, nevertheless they were legislative Anglican bishops of above-board Anglican Provinces, their attendance would go through affront Katie Jefferts-Schori. And just experience again how that Lambeth House of representatives was intentionally choreographed to avert any meaningful treatise of the real points of grounds. The Lambeth Archbishop of the Sudan even had to yell his own intimate get behind meeting to make a emit opposed to sexually reverse demeanor.

"It very gives the community entrance to incalculable raw materials for movement and cast."

I desire it be not true, but here may lie the real explanation of this on the other hand confusing change. From time to time, messages in the blogosphere go through lauded ACNA's campaign and appointments for evangelism, church planting, and church movement. "Strategy and appointments" seemingly intensify "raw materials" and, in the context of St. Charles' featuring this item, "raw materials" peek to study in the sphere of "liberated money, money we don't go through to speed up for ourselves".

It would be a minute ago sad if St. Charles' were to go through sold out its genuine Anglican pedigree for a tangle of accomodationist sauce. In the words of the in shreds near the beginning Black Sox fan who pled for guarantee from Shoeless Joe Jackson, "Say it ain't so, Joe."